Arizona does not allow same-sex marriage. What happens when a man who was
born as a woman, but had a sex change, though he still has female reproductive
organs, marries, moves to Arizona, and then decides he wants to divorce
his wife? What happens is a judge questions whether the man’s marriage
was legally valid in the first place.
Thomas Beatie is the man in question. He is a transgender man who is now
divorcing his wife Nancy.
Beatie was born as a woman in Hawaii, had a sex change in 1998, but retained
his female sex organs. He and his wife were married as man and wife in
2003. Both Beatie’s birth certificate and passport were changed
to identify him as a man.
Beatie and his wife wanted children, but since Nancy was infertile, Beatie
was the one who bore their three children. Beatie made headlines when
photos of him with a beard and pregnant belly were made public.
Although Hawaii recognizes Beatie as a man, Arizona does not because he
still has female reproductive organs. Beatie’s attorney, David Michael
Cantor stated that Hawaii said it was okay, the marriage was valid, but
“who is Arizona to say, well, we’re going to ignore one of
the other 49 states and say this is not a valid marriage?” This
is new territory for Arizona and Cantor is fighting to have the marriage
recognized. If the marriage is not recognized, Beatie will not have to pay
spousal maintenance, but this is something Beatie does not want.
He wants not only his marriage validated in Arizona, but wants to be recognized
as a male, as well.
According to TMZ, the judge in the case argues that since Arizona doesn’t
recognize gay marriage, he does not have the authority to
divorce a couple that, in his opinion, were never married in the first place.
Whatever decision the judge makes will set precedent in Arizona over transgender